The Three Laws of Open Government Data

Yesterday, at the Right To Know Week panel discussion – Conference for Parliamentarians: Transparency in the Digital Era – organized by the Office of the Information Commissioner I shared three laws for Open Government Data that I’d devised on the flight from Vancouver.

The Three Laws of Open Government Data:

  1. If it can’t be spidered or indexed, it doesn’t exist
  2. If it isn’t available in open and machine readable format, it can’t engage
  3. If a legal framework doesn’t allow it to be repurposed, it doesn’t empower

To explain, (1) basically means: Can I find it? If Google (and/or other search engines) can’t find it, it essentially doesn’t exist for most citizens. So you’d better ensure that you are optimized to be crawled by all sorts of search engine spiders.

After I’ve found it, (2) notes that, to be useful, I need to be able to play with the data. Consequently, I need to be able to pull or download it in a useful format (e.g. an API, subscription feed, or a documented file). Citizens need data in a form that lets them mash it up with Google Maps or other data sets, or analyze in Excel. This is essentially the difference between VanMaps (look, but don’t play) and the Vancouver Data Portal, (look, take and play!). Citizens who can’t play with information are citizens who are disengaged/marginalized from the discussion.

Finally, even if I can find it and play with it, (3) highlights that I need a legal framework that allows me to share what I’ve created, to mobilize other citizens, provide a new service or just point out an interesting fact. This is the difference between Canada’s House of Parliament’s information (which, due to crown copyright, you can take, play with, but don’t you dare share or re-publish) and say, which “pursuant to federal law, government-produced materials appearing on this site are not copyright protected.”

Find, Play and Share. That’s want we want.

Of course, a brief scan of the internet has revealed that others have also been thinking about this as well. There is this excellent 8 Principle of Open Government Data that are more detailed, and admittedly better, especially for a CIO level and lower conversation.  But for talking to politicians (or Deputy Ministers or CEOs), like those in attendance during yesterday’s panel or, later that afternoon, the Speaker of the House, I found the simplicity of three resonated more strongly; it is a simpler list they can remember and demand.

84 thoughts on “The Three Laws of Open Government Data

  1. Pingback: Open Data presentation at DemoCamp :

  2. Pingback: uberVU - social comments

  3. Pingback: telefreizeit

  4. Pingback: The Power of Open Data — Case Study: How Open Data Saved Canada $3.2 Billion « Legal Research Plus

  5. Pingback: Thursday, May 20, 2010 « The Jeff Farias Show

  6. Pingback: Confluence: Government Information Licensing Framework (GILF)

  7. Pingback: Open Data in Italia: dati utili e dati aperti bastano per una reale trasparenza? « YBlog

  8. Pingback: Does your Government (and thus you) actually own its data? |

  9. Pingback: As 3 leis do dado aberto governamental | Transparência Hack Day Pará

  10. Pingback: Mário Aragão – Desopilando » Dados abertos (open data)

  11. Pingback: Alberta’s Expert Monitoring Panel | Matthew Dance

  12. Pingback: Abian da GipuzkoaMatic, Foru Aldundiaren zerbitzu eta tresna digitalen bilgunea –

  13. Pingback: When information is power, these are the questions we should be asking | Online Journalism Blog

  14. Pingback: Dados governamentais abertos, e ai Zé? « Felipe Bergamo


  16. Pingback: 3 Steps to Consider When Pushing For Open Data in Government

  17. Pingback: Announcing the OpenCorporates Advisory Board… governance with teeth | OpenCorporates news

  18. Pingback: O que são dados abertos? « O Futuro é a Liberdade

  19. Pingback: Support for Open Data (and Big Data) in the HK Budget » Open Data Hong Kong - 開放資料香港

  20. Pingback: Consegi 2011: Dados abertos para democracia na era digital | LUZia Dourado

  21. Pingback: #codes » O que são dados abertos?

  22. Pingback: Dados abertos e o seu potencial para serviços – Economia de Serviços

  23. Pingback: Entenda o que são Dados Abertos! | SER Solução em Tecnologia da Informação

  24. Pingback: Dados públicos aberto no Brasil – analítica territorial

  25. Pingback: Portal Brasileiro de Dados Abertos | W7 Weslley

  26. Pingback: Desenvolvimento de sistemas de informação para biodiversidade – armadilhas e variáveis de sucesso – Eduardo Dalcin

  27. Pingback: Desenvolvimento de sistemas de informação para biodiversidade – armadilhas e variáveis de sucesso – Biodiversidade, Dados e Metadados

  28. Pingback: Desenvolvimento de sistemas de informação para biodiversidade – armadilhas e variáveis de sucesso | Biodiversidade, Dados e Metadados

  29. Pingback: 公開回應 PCM 電腦廣場:數據工作室並非提供「開放數據」 – Open Source Hong Kong

  30. Pingback: O que são dados abertos? – Human Privacy

  31. Pingback: O que são dados abertos governamentais?

  32. Pingback: Dados abertos possibilitam maior fiscalização por parte dos cidadãos – CGDF

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.